# How we compute: decision reports, their scores and verdicts

How the four decision reports find similar listings, work out every figure, score the measures and write the verdict, with every part, weight and threshold.

[Decision-making reports](https://showingtrail.com/decision-making-reports) · [Every method](https://showingtrail.com/methodology)

## Sources and licences

- [REALTOR.ca DDF® (CREA), current listings](https://www.crea.ca/), read at least daily: [CREA DDF® terms of use (display only; aggregate figures from current listings)](https://www.crea.ca/)
- [Table 10-10-0006-01, interest rates on new mortgage funds advanced, Bank of Canada](https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1010000601), monthly, about two months after the month (the release of 6 November 2026 carries August 2026); a saved rate is printed only while its month is the latest the table offers and the copy is under 45 days old: [Statistics Canada Open Licence](https://www.statcan.gc.ca/en/terms-conditions/open-licence)
- [Financial Information Return, Schedule 22 (property tax rates and levies)](https://efis.fma.csc.gov.on.ca/fir/index.php/en/open-data/fir-by-schedule-and-year/), 2025 and 2024 returns; 2023 and 2022 filings as built earlier: [Open Government Licence – Ontario](https://www.ontario.ca/page/open-government-licence-ontario)
- [Statistics Canada, Tables 34-10-0133-01 (average rents) and 34-10-0127-01 (vacancy rates), Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation](https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=3410012701), October 2025 surveys, released 17 December 2025: [Statistics Canada Open Licence; CMHC Licence Agreement for the Use of Data](https://www.statcan.gc.ca/en/terms-conditions/open-licence)
- [School information and student demographics 2024-2025](https://data.ontario.ca/dataset/school-information-and-student-demographics), extract of 18 August 2026; a re-issue of 14 September 2026 carries the same EQAO and enrolment figures: [Open Government Licence – Ontario](https://www.ontario.ca/page/open-government-licence-ontario)
- [OpenStreetMap, the Ontario extract (parks, places, buildings)](https://www.openstreetmap.org/copyright), the Ontario extract built 3 October 2026 on the site's server; the outdoors counts through the public Overpass API, built 3 October 2026 (scripts/build-outdoors.py): [Open Database License (ODbL)](https://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/)
- [Ontario Ministry of Transportation, Transit-Supportive Guidelines (2012)](https://www.ontario.ca/page/resources-transportation-planners), 2012, checked 25 October 2026: [Open Government Licence – Ontario](https://www.ontario.ca/page/open-government-licence-ontario)
- [ontario.ca, Residential rent increases; Guide to Ontario's standard lease; Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 and Condominium Act, 1998 (e-Laws)](https://www.ontario.ca/page/residential-rent-increases), checked 25 October 2026: [Open Government Licence – Ontario](https://www.ontario.ca/page/open-government-licence-ontario)
- [FCAC, Saving for a down payment](https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/services/mortgages/down-payment.html), read 30 September 2026: [public rules](https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/services/mortgages/down-payment.html)
- [CMHC, mortgage loan insurance cost](https://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/consumers/home-buying/mortgage-loan-insurance-for-consumers/cmhc-mortgage-loan-insurance-cost), read 25 October 2026: [public rules](https://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/consumers/home-buying/mortgage-loan-insurance-for-consumers/cmhc-mortgage-loan-insurance-cost)
- [OSFI, Minimum qualifying rate for uninsured mortgages](https://www.osfi-bsif.gc.ca/en/supervision/financial-institutions/banks/minimum-qualifying-rate-uninsured-mortgages), read 25 October 2026: [public rules](https://www.osfi-bsif.gc.ca/en/supervision/financial-institutions/banks/minimum-qualifying-rate-uninsured-mortgages)
- [Solar position equations (Global Monitoring Laboratory)](https://gml.noaa.gov/grad/solcalc/calcdetails.html), the calculation's page, unchanged: [US government work (public domain)](https://www.noaa.gov/disclaimer)

## How each figure is worked out

1. Similar listings are found as the listing page finds them: for each radius of about 1.5, 3 and 6 km in turn, the newest 100 active listings of the home's first building type with at least its bedrooms in the square around its map point, then the exact bedroom count (and, for rentals, a rent asked by the month); the first radius with at least 3 answers, and the listing itself is never among them. The 3 km sample of rentals is read as well, for the choice nearby.
2. The quartiles use the linear-between-closest-ranks method (spreadsheets' PERCENTILE.INC): h = (n − 1) × p, the value at ⌊h⌋ plus the fraction of the way to the next. With 3 or 4 listings only the lowest, the median and the highest are shown. A comparison is strong with 8 or more within about 1.5 or 3 km, fair with 5 or more at any radius or 3 or 4 within about 1.5 km, and thin otherwise.
3. Each check is a sum of parts. A part measures one figure against a named benchmark and turns it into points by straight lines through the breakpoints in the tables below, flat beyond the first and the last. A part whose figure cannot be measured is left out, and the total is scaled over the parts present: 100 × the points of the parts present ÷ their maximum. A score is shown only when the parts present carry at least 60 of the 100 points.
4. The bands describe the measures, never the home. The weights are this site's choice, printed beside each part so anyone can redo the sum with their own.
5. The verdict is written from the parts: the score and its band; where it stands up (up to two parts with 70% or more of their points, the highest share first, a tie to the larger maximum, then the table's order); where it falls short (up to two with 40% or less, the lowest first); and what no part measures. Every sentence of the middle two holds a figure and names its benchmark. It never uses the words should, must, recommend, advise, avoid, don't, do not, deal, bargain, steal, overpriced, underpriced, good buy, bad buy, pass on, worth it, risky, safe, dangerous or walk away.
6. Never scored: police-reported crime (Statistics Canada: the Crime Severity Index is not an indicator of overall safety), who lives in an area (scoring a home by its neighbours would rate people), climate and the conservation authority, sunlight (the window direction is the visitor's choice), whether a listing is accurate, and condition, renovations and lot size, which the feed does not reliably give.
7. Flags are questions to ask and facts; they never move a score, so a listing that states more never scores lower for it.
8. The money is worked out with the site's own calculators (the mortgage payment with semi-annual compounding, the CMHC premium, the land transfer taxes, the rental analysis, the hold projection, the seller's net and the capital gain) and the formulas in the table below; a figure with no published source is an Example or an Assumption, marked so and counted in each report's list of figures.
9. Sunlight is geometry from the sun's position at the home's map point, every 5 minutes of the year; the method is in the last table.

## Tenant's check: its parts, maxima, points and benchmarks

| Part | Max | Measured | Points | Benchmark and source | Missing when | Why this part, and these numbers |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| T-1 Rent against similar rentals | 40 | d = (asking rent − median) ÷ median | −10% → 40; 0 → 26; +10% → 10; +20% → 0 | the median asking rent of similar rentals (2.1), REALTOR.ca DDF® | fewer than 5 similar rentals | The rent is the largest money fact of a tenancy. 10% below the middle of the market saves more than a month's rent a year (1.2 months); 20% above it costs 2.4 months a year, and scores nothing. |
| T-2 Room to negotiate | 20 | Δ = days listed − the similar rentals' median days listed | −14 days → 0; 0 days → 10; +30 days → 20 | the same rentals | no days on market, or fewer than 5 similar rentals | A unit listed a month longer than similar ones has had fewer takers at its rent, which a tenant can point to. Rentals turn over in weeks, so the scale ends at a month. |
| T-3 Rent increase protection | 15 | the building type and the year built | an apartment or condominium built 2017 or earlier → 15; built 2019 or later → 0 | Ontario's rent increase guideline, which does not cover new buildings, additions and most new basement apartments first occupied after 15 November 2018 (ontario.ca, residential rent increases) | built in 2018, no year stated, or any other type (a unit in a house may have been first rented long after the house was built) | Under the guideline the rent can rise by at most 2.1% in 2026 and 1.9% in 2027; outside it, by any amount. That is the difference between a known and an unknown rent in later years. |
| T-4 What the listing states | 10 | k of 6 facts stated: parking, heating, cooling, laundry, size, what is included | 10 × k ÷ 6 | the listing's fields (T3) | never | Each fact not stated is one more thing to confirm before signing. It counts what is stated; it judges nothing about whether it is true. |
| T-5 Choice nearby | 15 | n = rentals with the same bedrooms and type within about 3 km | 0 → 0; 3 → 3; 8 → 9; 15 → 15 | the 3 km sample (2.1) | no map point, or the sample could not be read | Alternatives a short distance away give a tenant time and choice; past 15 more make little difference. |

## Landlord's check: its parts, maxima, points and benchmarks

| Part | Max | Measured | Points | Benchmark and source | Missing when | Why this part, and these numbers |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| L-1 Rent against similar rentals | 40 | d = (the rent − median) ÷ median | −20% → 16; −10% → 28; −3% → 40; +3% → 40; +10% → 20; +20% → 0 | the median asking rent of similar rentals | fewer than 5 similar rentals | Priced within 3% of the middle, a unit leases in the market's usual time. A month empty costs a twelfth of a year's rent (8.3%), so a rent 10% over the middle that adds one empty month earns about the same in the first year (1.10 × 11 = 12.1 months against 12), and anything higher loses. Below the middle the unit leases, but every month earns less. |
| L-2 Time on the market | 20 | Δ days as T-2 | 0 days → 20; +30 days → 10; +60 days → 0 | the same rentals | no days on market, or fewer than 5 similar rentals | Each month empty costs a month's rent. |
| L-3 Return on the value | 25 | spread = cap rate − the average rate charged on new five-year fixed mortgages, in percentage points | −3 points → 0; −1.5 points → 12.5; 0 points → 25 | the average rate charged on new five-year fixed mortgages (Statistics Canada, table 10-10-0006-01), with its month; the value is the visitor's, else the median asking price of similar homes for sale (apartments and townhouses only) | no value, no tax figure, or no mortgage rate | When the rent's net income is a smaller share of the value than the cost of borrowing, every borrowed dollar lowers the return; at or above that rate, borrowing adds to it. The spread is measured without the down payment, so every owner reads it alike. |
| L-4 Fixed costs against the rent | 15 | s = (yearly tax ÷ 12 + monthly fee) ÷ rent | 20% → 15; 45% → 0 | the listing's or the visitor's tax and fee | neither tax nor fee known | Tax and the fee are paid whether or not the unit is rented; what is left of each rent dollar pays the mortgage, repairs and empty months. |

## Buyer's check: its parts, maxima, points and benchmarks

| Part | Max | Measured | Points | Benchmark and source | Missing when | Why this part, and these numbers |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| B-1 Price against similar homes | 30 | d on the asking price per square foot when the listing and 5 or more comparables state a size, else on the asking price | −10% → 30; 0 → 18; +10% → 6; +20% → 0 | the median asking price of similar homes for sale, or their median asking price per square foot when it is measured on that (2.1) | fewer than 5 similar homes | The price is the largest money fact of a purchase; per square foot removes most of the difference in size. |
| B-2 Running costs | 15 | the mean of the measures available, × 15: (a) the municipality's lowest filed residential rate ÷ the median Ontario municipality's; (b) for a condominium, the fee per square foot ÷ the median of the building's units (3 or more), else of similar homes for sale (5 or more) | (a) 0.8 → 1; 1 → 0.5; 1.2 → 0. (b) 0.8 → 1; 1 → 0.5; 1.25 → 0 | FIR Schedule 22 (the filed rates and Ontario's median); fees as listed | neither measure known | The tax rate and the fee are paid every month for as long as you own. A bill is the rate times the assessment, so the rate is compared with Ontario's median, not this home's bill. |
| B-3 Schools nearby | 20 | the mean of the Ontario percentiles of the nearest English-language public school of each level within 5 km that has a score | 20 × mean ÷ 100 | the Showing Trail school score from the Ministry of Education's EQAO results, and its Ontario percentile | no such school with a score within 5 km | The English-language public boards' schools have no religious or language requirement (Education Act, s. 33), while Catholic and French-language boards admit by eligibility, so only the English public board's nearest school of each level is scored; the others are listed in the schools section, not scored. The percentile already compares with every Ontario school of the level. |
| B-4 Daily needs on foot | 20 | five needs, 4 points each, by the distance to the nearest | grocery store: 800 m → 4; 1.6 km → 2; none within 2 km → 0. pharmacy: 800 m → 4; 1.6 km → 2; none within 2 km → 0. park or playground: 400 m → 4; 800 m → 2; none within 1 km → 0. bus or streetcar stop: 400 m → 4; 500 m → 2; none within 500 m → 0. subway, go or lrt station: 800 m → 4; 1.6 km → 2; 3 km → 1; none within 3 km → 0 | © OpenStreetMap contributors, the server's Ontario extract; the sum, scaled over the needs that are known (a need whose search reaches off Ontario's land with nothing found is unknown) | no places data | 400 m is about a 5-minute walk and 800 m about 10 at the site's 80 m a minute; the Ontario Ministry of Transportation's Transit-Supportive Guidelines (2012) note that transit users are generally willing to walk 400 m to a local stop or 800 m to a rapid transit station. The places copy counts stops within 500 m only, hence that step. |
| B-5 Room to negotiate | 15 | Δ days as T-2 | −21 days → 0; 0 days → 7.5; +45 days → 15 | similar homes for sale | no days on market, or fewer than 5 similar homes for sale | Sales take longer than leases, so the scale runs to six weeks. |

## Investor's check: its parts, maxima, points and benchmarks

| Part | Max | Measured | Points | Benchmark and source | Missing when | Why this part, and these numbers |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| I-1 Monthly cash flow | 30 | c = monthly cash flow ÷ rent | −50% → 0; −25% → 8; 0 → 20; +10% → 30 | the rent used and the costs and financing shown | no rent, or no rate | The money the owner adds or receives each month is the plainest test of whether the rent carries the home. As a share of the rent, a $5,000 rent and a $2,000 rent are measured alike. |
| I-2 Cap rate against the borrowing rate | 20 | spread = cap rate − the average five-year fixed rate | −3 points → 0; −1.5 points → 10; 0 points → 20 | the average rate charged on new five-year fixed mortgages (Statistics Canada, table 10-10-0006-01), with its month | no rent, or no mortgage rate | Independent of the down payment, it says whether borrowing helps or hurts the return. |
| I-3 Debt coverage | 15 | net operating income ÷ the year's mortgage payments | 0.7 → 0; 1 → 9; 1.2 → 15 | arithmetic on the figures shown | no mortgage (100% down), or no rent | At 1.0 the rent's net income just pays the mortgage; above it there is room for an empty month or a repair. |
| I-4 Rental vacancy | 10 | CMHC's October vacancy rate for the metropolitan area | 1.5% → 10; 3% → 5; 5% → 0 | CMHC vacancy rates via Statistics Canada Table 34-10-0127-01 (2.6) | no published rate for the area | The share of rental units standing empty is the published measure of how readily units rent there. |
| I-5 Price against similar homes | 15 | d as B-1 | −10% → 15; 0 → 9; +10% → 3; +20% → 0 | as B-1 | as B-1 | The entry price sets every return figure above. |
| I-6 Room to negotiate | 10 | Δ days as B-5 | −21 days → 0; 0 days → 5; +45 days → 10 | as B-5 | as T-2 | As B-5. |

## The bands, the same for all four checks (a score is shown only when the parts measured carry at least 60 of the 100 points)

| Score | Band |
| --- | --- |
| 80 to 100 | Stands up well on these measures |
| 60 to 79 | Stands up on most of these measures |
| 40 to 59 | Mixed on these measures |
| 20 to 39 | Falls short on several of these measures |
| 0 to 19 | Falls short on most of these measures |

## The flags: questions to ask and facts, which never move a score

| Flag | Reports | Trigger | Source shown |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| F1 | tenant, landlord, investor | an apartment or condominium built 2017 or earlier | ontario.ca, residential rent increases |
| F2 | tenant, landlord, investor | an apartment or condominium built 2019 or later | ontario.ca, residential rent increases; Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, ss. 116 and 119 |
| F3 | tenant, landlord, investor | built in 2018, no year stated, or a house, townhouse or plex | ontario.ca, residential rent increases |
| F4 | buyer, investor, landlord | a condominium's fee per square foot 1.25 times or more the median of the building's units (3 or more stating both), else of similar homes for sale (5 or more) | fees as listed on the REALTOR.ca DDF® |
| F5 | buyer, investor, landlord | the same, 0.75 times or less | fees as listed on the REALTOR.ca DDF®; Condominium Act, 1998, s. 76 |
| F6 | investor, landlord | the fee is 25% or more of the rent used | the listing; the rent's own source |
| F7 | tenant, landlord, buyer, investor | listed 30 or more days (rentals) or 45 or more (sales) above the comparables' median, with 5 or more comparables | the DDF® record and the comparables |
| F8 | tenant, landlord, buyer, investor | this site recorded a change of the asking price | this site's own record of the asking price, and how it records it |
| F9 | tenant, landlord, investor | an apartment with 3 or more other units of its building listed for rent | the DDF®; the building profile's source |
| F10 | tenant, buyer, investor | bedrooms below grade, or a bedroom on a basement or lower level | the listing; Ontario's Building Code (O. Reg. 163/24, Division B, 9.9.10.1) |
| F11 | tenant, landlord | a rental whose unit, address or description says basement or lower level | the listing, quoted |
| F12 | buyer, investor | built before 1980 | the Electrical Safety Authority's homeowner pages |
| F13 | buyer, investor | a freehold house, townhouse or plex whose description gives no year for the roof | the listing |
| F14 | buyer, investor | water from a well | the listing; Public Health Ontario |
| F15 | buyer, investor | a septic system | the listing |
| F16 | buyer, investor | the description mentions a power of sale or an estate sale | the listing, quoted |
| F17 | buyer, investor | the description mentions an assignment | the listing, quoted |
| F18 | buyer, investor | a conservation authority regulates the area | Conservation authority administrative area (Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, via Ontario GeoHub); Conservation authority boundaries: Contains information licensed under the Open Government Licence – Ontario; the Conservation Authorities Act, s. 28 |
| F19 | buyer, investor | a condominium, unless the report's checklist already asks for its status certificate | the Condominium Act, 1998, s. 76; the Condominium Authority of Ontario |
| F20 | investor | a monthly cash flow below $0 | worked out |
| F21 | tenant, landlord | the rent is above the 75th percentile, 5 or more comparables | the DDF® |
| F22 | landlord | the rent is below the 25th percentile | the DDF® |
| F23 | buyer, investor | the listing states no property tax | Ontario Financial Information Return, Schedule 22 |
| F24 | buyer | a price of $1.5 million or more | CMHC, requirements for homeowner mortgage loan insurance |
| F25 | investor | always | CMHC Purchase and CMHC Income Property |
| F26 | investor | a duplex, triplex, fourplex or multi-family building | the listing |
| F27 | buyer, investor | leasehold, co-operative, life lease, timeshare or undivided co-ownership | the listing |
| F28 | tenant, landlord, buyer, investor | the seller withheld the address online | the listing |
| F29 | tenant, landlord, buyer, investor | the home's map point is the site's own (placed at its street address, or the board's put in order), and its address is shown | Showing Trail's own placement; Statistics Canada, National Address Register |

## The money formulas

| Figure | Formula |
| --- | --- |
| Break-even rent | R* = (F + P) ÷ (1 − v − m − g), where F = (yearly tax + yearly insurance) ÷ 12 + monthly fee + monthly utilities, P = the monthly mortgage payment, and v, m, g the vacancy, maintenance and management shares of the rent; none when 1 − v − m − g ≤ 0. |
| Gross rent multiplier | price ÷ (12 × rent). |
| An empty day | rent × 12 ÷ 365. |
| Cash flow before other costs | rent − payment − tax ÷ 12 − fee (the listing page's figure). |
| Landlord's return | NOI = 12 × rent × (1 − v) − operating costs; cap rate = NOI ÷ value; gross yield = 12 × rent ÷ value; monthly cash flow = NOI ÷ 12 − payment; debt coverage = NOI ÷ (12 × payment); cash return on equity = (NOI − 12 × payment) ÷ (value − balance). |
| Owner's month | the payment on the price less the down payment, plus the CMHC premium below 20% down (rated on the buyer's years for a first-time buyer, else at most 25), with semi-annual compounding; plus tax, fee, heat and insurance. The stress test: the payment at the greater of the rate + 2 points and 5.25% (OSFI B-20). |
| Down payment that breaks even | the least down payment from 20% to 100% of the price at which the monthly cash flow is $0 or more, found by bisection to the dollar; none when the cash flow at 100% is below $0. |
| A sale | value = price × (1 + growth)^years; net if sold = value − commission (4%) − 13% HST on it − legal fees ($1,500) − the mortgage balance. |
| Internal rate of return | the rate r at which Σ f_t ÷ (1 + r)^t = 0 over the yearly flows (the cash put in, each year's cash flow, the net if sold), by bisection from −99% to +100%; not defined when the sum does not change sign. |
| Growth needed | the least yearly growth, from −10% to +20%, at which the net if sold plus the cash flow equals the cash put in. |
| Taxable half | half of (the sale value − the selling costs − the price − the buying costs), for a home that is not a principal residence and is held 365 days or more. |

## Sunlight by window direction: the method

| Step | How |
| --- | --- |
| 1 | The sun's position is worked out with the equations NOAA's Global Monitoring Laboratory publishes for its solar calculator, which follow Jean Meeus, Astronomical Algorithms: the Julian century, the sun's mean longitude and anomaly, the equation of the centre, the apparent longitude, the obliquity of the ecliptic, the declination, the equation of time, the true solar time and hour angle, then the elevation and the azimuth from north. |
| 2 | Refraction is not added: the sun counts from 0° geometric elevation, so its first and last minutes fall a few minutes inside the published sunrise and sunset. |
| 3 | The sun is on a window facing N 0°, NE 45°, E 90°, SE 135°, S 180°, SW 225°, W 270° or NW 315° when it is above the horizon and less than 90° from the way the window faces. |
| 4 | Every 5 minutes of every day of the year in Toronto time is sampled: the hours a day for each direction are averaged over each month and added up for the year; 21 June and 21 December are shown with their clock times in Toronto, daylight time applied. |
| 5 | Neighbouring buildings, trees, balconies and the home's own walls are not counted, so every figure is an upper bound. The floor changes nothing in this geometry: it matters only once neighbouring buildings are counted, which the site's map data cannot yet do honestly. |
| 6 | A home whose address is not published is worked out at its rounded map point; a kilometre changes these hours by seconds. |

## What it cannot tell you

- Asking prices and asking rents of active listings, never sale prices or agreed rents: the DDF® carries neither.
- A sample is the newest 100 listings of its search before the exact bedroom count is applied.
- Rentals typed House include whole houses and units within houses, which the listing data does not tell apart.
- Days on market start again when a home is taken off the market and listed again.
- Price changes are only those this site saw: the direction and the count, never an amount.
- The mortgage rate is Statistics Canada's average of the rates charged on new five-year fixed mortgages in a month; the rate a borrower is offered can differ.
- Property assessments are still at 2016 values, so a tax worked out from a filed rate and today's price is an upper figure.
- A score describes its measures, not a home's condition, value or suitability for anyone, and the weights are this site's choice, published so anyone can redo the sum.
- Sunlight counts no neighbouring building, tree or balcony: every figure is an upper bound.

Figures from the public sources named above, as published on the dates shown; they may be out of date or differ from the source, and this site is not the source, so check with it before you rely on a figure.
